SOX vs SOC Reports: Differences, SOC 1 vs SOC 2 and Who Needs Each
SOX is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, a US law that requires public companies to maintain and report on internal control over financial reporting, with auditor attestation under Section 404.
Topic: SOC & Blue Team in Cybersecurity & Ethical Hacking · Comparison
Also covers: Cybersecurity Foundations
Quick answer: SOX is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, a US law that requires public companies to maintain and report on internal control over financial reporting, with auditor attestation under Section 404. SOC reports are independent auditor reports under AICPA standards that describe a service organisation's controls: SOC 1 covers controls relevant to customers' financial reporting, SOC 2 covers security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy, and SOC 3 is a public summary. They connect: a public company's SOX auditors often rely on its vendors' SOC 1 reports.
Key takeaways
- SOX is a legal obligation for US-listed companies; SOC is a voluntary attestation for service providers.
- SOC 1 supports customers' financial audits; SOC 2 addresses security and related trust criteria.
- Type 1 tests design at a point in time; Type 2 tests operating effectiveness over a period.
- IT general controls such as access, change management and backups matter to both.
- Indian companies have similar internal financial control duties under the Companies Act 2013.
Table of Contents
- What Does SOX Require?
- What Are SOC Reports?
- How Do SOX and SOC Compare?
- Which IT Controls Matter to Both?
- What Does Control Evidence Look Like?
- How Does This Apply in India?
- References
What Does SOX Require?
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act followed accounting scandals in the early 2000s. Section 302 requires the CEO and CFO to certify financial reports and controls. Section 404 requires management to assess internal control over financial reporting, and for larger filers, the external auditor to attest to it under PCAOB AS 2201.
What Are SOC Reports?
| Report | Focus | Audience |
|---|---|---|
| SOC 1 | Controls relevant to customers' financial reporting | Customers and their auditors |
| SOC 2 | Trust Services Criteria: security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, privacy | Customers, prospects, regulators, under NDA |
| SOC 3 | Summary of SOC 2 results | General public |
Security is the mandatory common criteria in every SOC 2; the other four categories are chosen based on the service. The criteria are published by the AICPA as the Trust Services Criteria.
How Do SOX and SOC Compare?
| SOX | SOC reports | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | US federal law | Attestation reports under AICPA standards |
| Who | US-listed public companies | Service organisations such as SaaS, payroll, data centres |
| Scope | Internal control over financial reporting | Controls at the service provider |
| Required? | Yes, by law | Voluntary, often demanded by customers |
| Oversight | SEC and PCAOB | AICPA standards, licensed CPA firms |
Which IT Controls Matter to Both?
- Access management: joiner, mover and leaver processes; quarterly access reviews.
- Change management: approved, tested and logged changes to systems.
- Operations: monitored batch jobs, backups and incident handling.
- Segregation of duties: developers cannot deploy their own code to production unreviewed.
What Does Control Evidence Look Like?
Auditors ask for evidence that controls ran, not just policies. For a quarterly access review, an export compared with HR records is typical:
import csv
active_staff = {r["email"].lower() for r in csv.DictReader(open("hr_active.csv"))}
findings = []
for r in csv.DictReader(open("erp_users.csv")):
if r["email"].lower() not in active_staff and r["status"] == "enabled":
findings.append((r["username"], r["role"], r["last_login"]))
print(f"{len(findings)} enabled accounts without an active employee")
for f in findings:
print(*f, sep=" ")
Keep the output, the reviewer's sign-off and the tickets that removed access. Linux change evidence can include package histories:
sudo dnf history list | head -20
sudo ausearch -m USER_CMD --start this-month | aureport -x --summary
How Does This Apply in India?
The Companies Act 2013 requires directors of listed companies to confirm adequate internal financial controls (Section 134(5)(e)), and auditors to report on them (Section 143(3)(i)). Indian IT and SaaS firms serving US clients are frequently asked for SOC 1 or SOC 2 reports. See the Ministry of Corporate Affairs for the Act's text.
Read our guides on PCI DSS and sensitive information, or talk to a WebAsha training advisor about GRC and audit training.
References
Frequently Asked Questions
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0